| School |
Nickname |
City |
State |
Other affiliations |
|---|
| Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
Panthers |
Albany |
New York |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| Andrews University |
Cardinals |
Berrien Springs |
Michigan |
|
| The Apprentice School |
Builders |
Newport News |
Virginia |
New South Athletic Conference |
| Atlantis University |
Atlanteans |
Miami |
Florida |
New South Athletic Conference |
| Bay Path University |
Wildcats |
Longmeadow |
Massachusetts |
|
| Beacon College |
Blazers |
Leesburg |
Florida |
New South Athletic Conference |
| Berkeley College |
Knights |
Woodland Park and New York |
New Jersey and New York |
Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Albany |
Bobcats |
Albany |
New York |
|
| Bryant & Stratton College, Buffalo |
Bobcats |
Buffalo |
New York |
|
| Bryant & Stratton College, Ohio |
Bobcats |
Solon |
Ohio |
Ohio Community College Athletic Conference (NJCAA) |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Rochester |
Bobcats |
Rochester |
New York |
|
| Bryant & Stratton College, Syracuse |
Bobcats |
Syracuse |
New York |
|
| Bucks County Community College |
Centurions |
Newtown |
Pennsylvania |
Eastern Pennsylvania Athletic Conference (NJCAA)
Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Carlow University |
Celtics |
Pittsburgh |
Pennsylvania |
Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (NCAA Division III) |
| California Miramar University (provisional member) |
Fighting Falcons |
La Puente |
California |
|
| Central Maine Community College |
Mustangs |
Auburn |
Maine |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| Central Penn College |
Knights |
Summerdale |
Pennsylvania |
Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Christendom College |
Crusaders |
Front Royal |
Virginia |
Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| University of Cincinnati Clermont College |
Cougars |
Batavia |
Ohio |
|
| Colorado Mountain College – Leadville |
Eagles |
Leadville |
Colorado |
NJCAA |
| Crown College |
Royal Crusaders |
Powell |
Tennessee |
|
| Diné College |
Warriors |
Tsaile |
Arizona |
|
| East–West University |
Phantoms |
Chicago |
Illinois |
|
| Five Towns College |
Sounds |
Dix Hills |
New York |
Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Florida National University |
Conquistadors |
Hialeah |
Florida |
Continental Athletic Conference (NAIA) |
| Great Bay Community College |
Herons |
Portsmouth |
New Hampshire |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| Hampshire College |
Black Sheep |
Amherst |
Massachusetts |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| John Melvin Christian College (exploratory member) |
Mohawks |
Pensacola |
Florida |
New South Athletic Conference |
| John Melvin University (exploratory member) |
Millers |
Crowley |
Louisiana |
New South Athletic Conference |
| Johnson & Wales University Charlotte |
Wildcats |
Charlotte |
North Carolina |
Coast to Coast Athletic Conference (NCAA Division III) in July 2025 |
| Kennebec Valley Community College (provisional member) |
|
Fairfield and Hinckley |
Maine |
|
| Kent State University Tuscarawas |
Golden Eagles |
New Philadelphia |
Ohio |
|
| Lyon College |
Scots |
Batesville |
Arkansas |
St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (NCAA Division III) |
| University of Maine at Augusta |
Moose |
Augusta |
Maine |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| University of Maine at Fort Kent |
Bengals |
Fort Kent |
Maine |
|
| Manor College |
Blue Jays |
Jenkintown |
Pennsylvania |
Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Miami University Hamilton |
Harriers |
Hamilton |
Ohio |
|
| Miami University Middletown |
Thunderhawks |
Middletown |
Ohio |
|
| Mid-Atlantic Christian University |
Mustangs |
Elizabeth City |
North Carolina |
New South Athletic Conference |
| Navajo Technical University |
Skyhawks |
Crownpoint |
New Mexico |
|
| NHTI, Concord's Community College |
Lynx |
Concord |
New Hampshire |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| North American University |
Stallions |
Stafford |
Texas |
Red River Athletic Conference (NAIA) |
| Paul Quinn College |
Tigers |
Dallas |
Texas |
Red River Athletic Conference (NAIA) |
| Paul Smith's College |
Bobcats |
Paul Smiths |
New York |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| Penn State Beaver |
Nittany Lions |
Monaca |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State DuBois |
Nittany Lions |
DuBois |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Fayette, The Eberly Campus |
Nittany Lions |
Uniontown |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Greater Allegheny |
Nittany Lions |
McKeesport |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Hazleton |
Nittany Lions |
Hazleton |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Lehigh Valley |
Nittany Lions |
Center Valley |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Mont Alto |
Nittany Lions |
Mont Alto |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State New Kensington |
Nittany Lions |
New Kensington |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Schuylkill |
Nittany Lions |
Schuylkill Haven |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Scranton |
Nittany Lions |
Dunmore |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Shenango |
Nittany Lions |
Sharon |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Wilkes-Barre |
Nittany Lions |
Back Mountain |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State York |
Nittany Lions |
York |
Pennsylvania |
Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Quincy College |
Granite |
Quincy |
Massachusetts |
Massachusetts Community College Athletic Association (NJCAA) |
| Salem University |
Tigers |
Salem |
West Virginia |
Independent (NCAA Division II) |
| Shaw University |
Bears |
Raleigh |
North Carolina |
Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association (NCAA Division II) |
| Southeastern Illinois College |
Falcons |
Harrisburg |
Illinois |
NJCAA Division I |
| Southern California Leadership University (provisional member) |
Rhinos |
Westminster |
California |
|
| Southern Maine Community College |
SeaWolves |
South Portland |
Maine |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| Southwestern Adventist University |
Knights |
Keene |
Texas |
NCCAA Division II |
| Stanton University |
Fighting Elks |
Garden Grove |
California |
|
| SUNY Environmental Science and Forestry |
Mighty Oaks |
Syracuse |
New York |
Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Trinity College of Florida (provisional member) |
Tigers |
Trinity |
Florida |
|
| United International College |
Eagle Rays |
Miramar |
Florida |
|
| United States Sports Academy (provisional member) |
Eagles |
Daphne |
Alabama |
|
| Vaughn College |
Warriors |
Flushing |
New York |
|
| Vermont State Randolph (Vermont Tech) |
Green Knights |
Randolph Center |
Vermont |
Yankee Small College Conference |
| Villa Maria College |
Vikings |
Buffalo |
New York |
Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Washington County Community College |
Golden Eagles |
Calais |
Maine |
|
| Williamson College of the Trades |
Mechanics |
Media |
Pennsylvania |
Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Word of Life Bible Institute/Davis College |
Huskies |
Pottersville |
New York |
Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Wright State University-Lake Campus |
Lakers |
Celina |
Ohio |
|
| York County Community College |
Hawks |
Wells |
Maine |
Yankee Small College Conference |